• About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
The Wellesley News -
  • News and Features
    • The Wellesley (COVID) 100
      The Wellesley (COVID) 100
    • In memory of Professor Rebecca Summerhays
      In memory of Professor Rebecca Summerhays
    • Trans flag controversy: College power washes staircase after trans flag is painted over Harry Potter spray paint
      Trans flag controversy: College power washes staircase after trans flag is painted over Harry Potter spray paint
    • News
      • News in Brief
      • Nation & World
      • President’s Corner
      • Senate Report
    • Features
      • Alumnae Spotlight
      • Eye on Science
      • Faculty Focus
      • LGBTQIA+ Column
  • Opinions
    • The News in Conversation: Wellesley Against Mass Incarceration
      The News in Conversation: Wellesley Against Mass Incarceration
    • Editorial Board calls for keeping up trans flag murals
      Editorial Board calls for keeping up trans flag murals
    • No, Elon Musk’s Twitter will not restore free speech
      No, Elon Musk’s Twitter will not restore free speech
    • Staff Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
    • The Elephant in the Room
  • Arts
    • Be/longing Centers Connection and Care
      Be/longing Centers Connection and Care
    • No image
      Birds Falling Upwards: Wellesley College Theater’s The Moors is a Must-See
    • No image
      Sometimes you just need to read a YA “Groundhog Day” to feel something
    • Arts In The News
    • Reviews
    • Music Peek
    • Books Before Boys
  • Health and Wellness
    • February Student Athlete of the Month
      February Student Athlete of the Month
    • Athletics Update
      Athletics Update
    • Victoria Garrick Speaks on Mental Health
      Victoria Garrick Speaks on Mental Health
    • Athlete of the Week
    • Boston Sports Update
    • The Vegan Digest
    • The SHE Corner
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • Wellesley News Leadership Changes Completely Peacefully Without Any Suspicious Disappearances At All
      Wellesley News Leadership Changes Completely Peacefully Without Any Suspicious Disappearances At All
    • Solve Your Connection Problems With Wellesley Insecure
      Solve Your Connection Problems With Wellesley Insecure
    • Mayhem strikes Wellesley as paper towels removed from campus
      Mayhem strikes Wellesley as paper towels removed from campus
  • Miscellanea
    • President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
      President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
    • Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
      Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
    • 50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
      50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
    • The Dose
    • The Olive Branch
    • Multimedia
      • Galleries
      • Infographics
      • Videos
By Mary Meisenzahl OpinionsSeptember 29, 2017

Harvard fails to live up to mission by rescinding fellowship to Chelsea Manning

Photo courtesy of Tim Travers Hawkins

The Institute of Politics at Harvard Kennedy School recently rescinded an offer to Chelsea Manning as a visiting fellow. In the Kennedy School’s announcement of her invitation to the fellowship, they described Manning as “a trans woman, [who] advocates for queer and transgender rights as @ xychelsea on Twitter. Following her court martial conviction in 2013 for releasing confidential military and State Department documents, President Obama commuted her 35-year sentence, citing it as “disproportionate” to the penalties faced by other whistleblowers.” After Manning’s invitation, CIA director Mike Pompeo dropped out of a speaking engagement at Harvard, which he says “has everything to do with her identity as a traitor to the United States of America and my loyalty to the officers of the CIA” Soon after, Dean Elmendorf of the Harvard Kennedy School called Manning to tell her she had been disinvited. Manning responded with several tweets saying “this is what a military/police/ intel state looks like the cia determines what is and is not taught at harvard #WeGotThis .” Harvard’s withdrawal of its fellowship offer to Chelsea Manning is a disappointing demonstration of the school’s unwillingness to engage with unpopular or unpleasant ideas.

Calling Chelsea Manning a traitor is a disingenuous representation of her actions, in which she informed the world and the American people of military acts being carried out in their name. However, even if Pompeo subscribes to the idea that Manning’s leaks were immoral, Harvard was not obligated to rescind Manning’s invitation at his request. Perhaps Harvard does not want to fall out of favor with potential donors and speakers who are involved with the military. Inviting Manning would have carried out Harvard’s motto “Veritas,” or “truth.” As a whistleblower, she made the world aware of U.S. military actions abroad including footage of a strike on New Baghdad referred to by Wikileaks as “Collateral Murder.” This footage showed two U.S. helicopters attacking a group of unarmed men, including two Reuters reporters.

In order for an institution to represent itself as seeking out the truth, it should be willing and eager to invite dissenting viewpoints and hear truths that may be unpleasant. The fact that Manning could bring to Harvard the reality of the United States’ military’s actions in Iraq and subsequent human rights abuses she faced in weeks of solitary confinement following her conviction were no doubt disagreeable to government officials like Pompeo. If they try to use their influence on the university to have her uninvited, that should be all the more reason to invite her. The director of the CIA should not be deciding what is and is not worthy of discussion at American universities.

Uninviting Chelsea Manning was a poor use of Harvard’s considerable influence. According to the school’s website, “The John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University is a graduate and professional school that brings together students, scholars and practitioners who combine thought and action to make the world a better place.” As a former intelligence analyst who leaked documents from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, Manning is in a position to use her visibility and fame to draw attention to U.S. war crimes. The world could be a better place for knowing and discussing the atrocities of war and using that discussion to make them less frequent.

Dean Elmendorf wrote in his statement that in disinviting Manning, he was clarifying that Harvard did not intend to honor or endorse her. Judging by the year’s current list of fellows, which includes Sean Spicer and Corey Lewandowski, Harvard believes these men are worthy of discussion while Manning is not. Chelsea Manning’s fellowship could have been a sign of Harvard’s willingness to discuss controversial and uncomfortable topics with meaningful speakers but, with her disinvitation, they have failed at their own mission.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleDeVos should not defend perpetrators at the expense of survivors
Next articleSlang should be adopted into newer versions of dictionary

You may also like

The News in Conversation: Wellesley Against Mass Incarceration

Editorial Board calls for keeping up trans flag murals

No, Elon Musk’s Twitter will not restore free speech

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

Top Articles

Sorry. No data so far.

Recent Tweets

Tweets by @Wellesley_News

The independent student newspaper of Wellesley College since 1901.

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

  • About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
COPYRIGHT © 2022 THE WELLESLEY NEWS
Back to top