facebook icon facebook icon facebook icon
  • About
  • ADS
  • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
  • Subscribe
The Wellesley News -
  • News
    • Wellesley Students Comment on Recent State Elections
      Wellesley Students Comment on Recent State Elections
    • Still No Student Bursar: It’s Not Just a Money Problem
      Still No Student Bursar: It’s Not Just a Money Problem
    • Students question administration’s comments on demonstration policy
      Students question administration’s comments on demonstration policy
    • Senate Report
    • News in Brief
  • Features
    • Professor Selwyn Cudjoe Set To Retire After 38 Years At Wellesley: Africana Studies department hosts lecture series in his honor
      Professor Selwyn Cudjoe Set To Retire After 38 Years At Wellesley: Africana Studies department hosts lecture series in his honor
    • Lines and Light: Vera Pavlova’s Poetry in “The Line of Contact”
      Lines and Light: Vera Pavlova’s Poetry in “The Line of Contact”
    • Tanner Conference: A look into STEM Students Summer Experiences
      Tanner Conference: A look into STEM Students Summer Experiences
  • Opinions
    • We don’t all have to be doctors
      We don’t all have to be doctors
    • Letter to the Editor: do you condemn Israel?
      Letter to the Editor: do you condemn Israel?
    • Arabs and Muslims will speak for ourselves
      Arabs and Muslims will speak for ourselves
    • Editorials
    • Letters to Editors
  • Arts
    • Brandeis-Wellesley Orchestra celebrates 20th anniversary
      Brandeis-Wellesley Orchestra celebrates 20th anniversary
    • Marvel does “Loki” justice with its second season.
      Marvel does “Loki” justice with its second season.
    • SAG-AFTRA reaches tentative deal with studios
      SAG-AFTRA reaches tentative deal with studios
  • Sports
    • The Wellesley Blue is Off to a Powerful Winter Season
      The Wellesley Blue is Off to a Powerful Winter Season
    • Bringing Back the Wellesley College 50 list!
      Bringing Back the Wellesley College 50 list!
    • Sports Week Cheat Sheet: Top Five Moments
      Sports Week Cheat Sheet: Top Five Moments
  • Multimedia
    • Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
      Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
    • Photo of the Week
      Photo of the Week
    • “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
      “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
    • Podcasts
    • Photo Stories
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • How I Transformed My Life Using Kiki and Bouba Theory
      How I Transformed My Life Using Kiki and Bouba Theory
    • America… America has a problem.
      America… America has a problem.
    • A Wellesley Snooze Need to Know: Why Won’t Obama Release his LSAT Scores?
      A Wellesley Snooze Need to Know: Why Won’t Obama Release his LSAT Scores?
  • About
    • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
By Emily Fu Multicultural Column, News, News and FeaturesApril 11, 2018

Why diversity in fiction matters

In my senior year at Peddie School, a college preparatory school in New Jersey, I studied Graham Greene’s “The Quiet American.” Set during the French war in Vietnam, this novel centers around the relationships between the narrator Fowler, a British reporter; his Vietnamese mistress, Phuong; and an American, Pyle, who has fallen in love with Phuong. The novel, a scathing attack on what Fowler refers to as “American innocence,” reveals Fowler and Pyle’s perspectives— both Western perspectives— on the war in Vietnam. Yet we see Phuong only as a simple character, characterized solely by her beauty, her desire to marry for financial security and words like “wonderfully ignorant” and “child-like.” While reading the novel, I constantly thought to myself, “Where is Phuong’s perspective?” Although Fowler and Pyle perceived Phuong as lacking human depth and complexity, I wanted to believe that she was more than how they perceived her.

When I was younger, I did not notice that the characters I read were mostly white. I did not notice that the new worlds I had fallen in love with didn’t include people that looked like me. These worlds were as white as the world I lived in, as white as the culture I immersed myself in, the TV shows and movies I consumed, the music I listened to. Asian characters were often either left out of narratives entirely or portrayed as tropes, such as prostitutes or geeks. Reading Greene’s “The Quiet American” was the first time I began to recognize my own deep need to see myself reflected in the books I read. I yearned for someone who looked like me to be represented authentically and fully. I was tired of reading yet another depiction of an Asian character as one-dimensional.

While “The Quiet American” is a historical novel, Fowler and Pyle’s perceptions of Phuong reflect a society that still to this day silences and dehumanizes Asians. Growing up in a small, predominantly white town in New Jersey, I encountered people whose false assumptions about Asians mirrored the assumptions that book characters had. Some people had difficulty viewing me as an American and could not see me as anything other than a perpetual foreigner. It hurt when I saw others as complex human beings and unique individuals, only to realize that they either did not see me at all or viewed me as indistinguishable from all the other billions of Asians in the world. Perhaps I so desperately wanted to believe that Greene’s character Phuong’s had hidden depth and hear her side of the story because I saw in her both myself and others in society who have been perceived as one-dimensional and whose stories are unheard and underrepresented.

Diverse perspectives in fiction matter because reading books helps us understand ourselves and  others. The lack of representation and misrepresentation of Asian characters in books prevents people of all races from seeing Asians beyond racial stereotypes and sends an implicit message to Asians that they do not matter enough to be represented. When all you read are one-dimensional versions of yourself, it can be difficult to imagine future possibilities for yourself and to believe that you are just as important and interesting as your white peers. By seeking Phuong’s perspective and imagining her as a more developed character, I was empowering myself, even though I did not know it at the time.

At Wellesley, the day after the dreary storm in March I began reading stories written by writer, poet and essayist Jenny Zhang. Zhang’s body of work focuses on Chinese American immigrant identity and experience in the United States. I began reading at noon. Hours later, the sun was beginning to set, turning the sky dusky blue and purple, and I was still reading Zhang’s stories. I hadn’t realized how desperately I craved reading about characters who looked like me. Finally, with Zhang’s stories, I read about Asian-American characters that were compelling, uncontrived and most of all, beautifully complex. Zhang’s characters were not uninspiring racial archetypes; they were not “wonderfully ignorant.” They were individuals who lived and experienced life in rich, saturated colors. Until that evening, I had not realized how desperately I craved reading stories like these and how good it felt to be seen.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleWellesley professor publishes book explaining motivations behind environmental choices
Next articleRegeneration gives students a chance to get their hands dirty: Growing plants on a century-old plot of land

You may also like

Wellesley Students Comment on Recent State Elections

Still No Student Bursar: It’s Not Just a Money Problem

Students question administration’s comments on demonstration policy

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Wellesley News

    SECTIONS

  • News
  • Features
  • Opinions
  • Arts
  • Sports
  • Multimedia
  • Projects
  • About

    ABOUT

  • Contact
  • Join the News
  • Masthead
  • Editorial Board

    RESOURCES

  • Advertising
  • Submission
  • Subscribe

    CONTACT US

  • Contact
COPYRIGHT © 2023 THE WELLESLEY NEWS