facebook icon facebook icon facebook icon
  • About
  • ADS
  • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
  • Submission
  • Subscribe
The Wellesley News -
  • News
    • Contract ratified by Wellesley’s Maintenance and Service Employees Union
      Contract ratified by Wellesley’s Maintenance and Service Employees Union
    • News in Brief
      News in Brief
    • Wellesley adapts to end of race conscious admissions
      Wellesley adapts to end of race conscious admissions
    • Senate Report
    • News in Brief
  • Features
    • Professor Spotlight: Dr. Faisal Ahmed
      Professor Spotlight: Dr. Faisal Ahmed
    • Spotlight: New Professor Kathryn Winner
      Spotlight: New Professor Kathryn Winner
    • Spotlight: New Professor Lucia Nhamo ’11
      Spotlight: New Professor Lucia Nhamo ’11
    • Humans of Wellesley
    • Archives
  • Opinions
    • France’s Abaya Ban Unveils Its Own Misogyny
      France’s Abaya Ban Unveils Its Own Misogyny
    • Editorial: In defense of affirmative action
      Editorial: In defense of affirmative action
    • I am an NCAA champion: we should end college recruiting
      I am an NCAA champion: we should end college recruiting
    • Editorials
    • Letters to Editors
  • Arts
    • The SAG-AFTRA and WGA Strikes: What’s happening in Hollywood?
      The SAG-AFTRA and WGA Strikes: What’s happening in Hollywood?
    • Digging into Hozier’s Unreal Unearth: “De Selby (Part 1)” and the Population of Loss
      Digging into Hozier’s Unreal Unearth: “De Selby (Part 1)” and the Population of Loss
    • Summer Releases to Help Usher in Fall
      Summer Releases to Help Usher in Fall
  • Sports
    • Gauff and Richardson Shatter Expectations
      Gauff and Richardson Shatter Expectations
    • Student Athlete of the Month: Kennedy Mayo
      Student Athlete of the Month: Kennedy Mayo
    • No image
      What even is a BORG and why does it matter?
  • Multimedia
    • Photo of the Week
      Photo of the Week
    • “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
      “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
    • College Government Vice President 2016 End of the Year Report
      College Government Vice President 2016 End of the Year Report
    • Podcasts
    • The Wellesley Snooze
  • Projects
      • The News in Conversation
    • About
      • Contact
      • Join the News
      • Masthead
      • Editorial Board
    By Jacqueline Roderick OpinionsOctober 2, 2019

    Whistleblowing is not a crime

    Freedom of speech is  one of the most important civil liberties granted to the people of the United States. The First Amendment allows citizens to openly and safely critique our government and our country in order to make it a better, more righteous place for everyone. 

    It is the actions of whistleblowers, however, that truly uphold the values enshrined in the United States’ founding documents. Without Smedley Butler, we would not have known of the “business plot” by rich businessmen to lead a coup d’etat during Roosevelt’s presidency. Without Daniel Ellsberg, we would not have known of the blatant lying and wrongdoing by the US government regarding the public’s knowledge on the Vietnam War. And without Edward Snowden, we would not have known of the mass national surveillance program, PRISM, which collects data from internet companies and then details and records our every digital move. 

    Edward Snowden evaded charges of theft of government property and of violating the Espionage Act after blowing the whistle on PRISM and the National Security Agency (NSA) back in 2013 by seeking asylum in Russia. He now delivers paid talks about his findings to various groups. Snowden recently published a memoir titled “Permanent Record,” which details his life, his motivations for releasing the NSA information and what exactly those revelations were. Nothing he published was outside of the public’s knowledge, yet the Department of Justice is suing Snowden for breaching his “secrecy agreements and non-disclosure obligations” by not filing the memoir through the department before publishing it, according to the suit. 

    The United States has a terrible record in dealing with whistleblowers, and this case is no different. Snowden has resided in Russia since 2013 and over the past six years, he has successfully evaded the US government. To file a suit against a man who no longer works for the NSA seems fruitless and redundant, but after years of cover-ups, this is pretty much just business as usual for the Department of Justice. 

    Whistleblowers like Snowden blatantly and intentionally violate laws for public interest. Often times, these laws are restrictive to free speech in nature, and do nothing to promote free thought. The Espionage Act of 1917 is one particular thorn in history’s side, which was first instituted when propaganda machines like the Committee on Public Intelligence reigned throughout World War I. Eugene V. Debs comes to mind as one of the first victims of this paranoia influenced law. While not a whistleblower, Debs wrote and delivered an anti-war speech and was subsequently sentenced to prison, violating the act with his “un-American actions.” Snowden, Ellsberg and Debs — three important, impactful1 and certainly controversial figures in American history — were all charged under this law. Ellsberg was acquitted, Debs was convicted and Snowden is still considered a fugitive wanted under the act. 

    Even when we do not consider the Espionage Act, we can still note the many times in history where whistleblowers were punished for simply revealing ugly truths in our various institutions, both private and public. Ronald J. Goldstein was fired by EBASCO, a contracting company, for reporting a lack of workplace safety in 1985. Jesselyn Radnack, a lawyer for the DOJ, was fired and had her license revoked after she told “Newsweek” about the destruction and lies surrounding documents in a case of a US citizen turned Taliban sympathizer in 2005. Reality Winner is currently serving five years in prison for leaking NSA documents regarding Russian interference in the 2016 election to a news outlet. 

    In 2019, we can look back on our nation’s 243 year history and know that not all laws created are just. The powerful institutions that enact and enforce those laws, in their blind following of the law, grow corrupt in nature and need to be checked. Whistleblowers fight to check the power of these institutions and work to ensure that what is actually happening is revealed, regardless of whatever version of the facts the public receives. It is because of the brave people like them that we are able to make informed decisions on our political, social and economic lives, and in a world where “fake news” prevails, we find gritty, ugly and necessary truth. 

    Share on

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Google +
    • LinkedIn
    • Email
    Previous articleDark money, darker pasts and the darkest consequences
    Next articleAn avoidable murder of a student caught on tape: the sickening power of the bystander effect

    You may also like

    France’s Abaya Ban Unveils Its Own Misogyny

    Editorial: In defense of affirmative action

    I am an NCAA champion: we should end college recruiting

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    The Wellesley News

      SECTIONS

    • News
    • Features
    • Opinions
    • Arts
    • Sports
    • Multimedia
    • Projects
    • About

      ABOUT

    • Contact
    • Join the News
    • Masthead
    • Editorial Board

      RESOURCES

    • Advertising
    • Submission
    • Subscribe

      CONTACT US

    • Contact
    COPYRIGHT © 2023 THE WELLESLEY NEWS