facebook icon facebook icon facebook icon
  • About
  • ADS
  • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
  • Subscribe
The Wellesley News -
  • News
    • Wellesley students join thousands marching for Palestine in Boston
      Wellesley students join thousands marching for Palestine in Boston
    • Wellesley students react to recent events in Israel & Palestine
      Wellesley students react to recent events in Israel & Palestine
    • No image
      Cabinet Column 10/25/23
    • Senate Report
    • News in Brief
  • Features
    • Wellesley MMUF fellows present at Northeast Regional Undergraduate Conference
      Wellesley MMUF fellows present at Northeast Regional Undergraduate Conference
    • A Single Turn: Alum Sandy Sugawara’s Book “Show Me the Way to Go to Home”
      A Single Turn: Alum Sandy Sugawara’s Book “Show Me the Way to Go to Home”
    • SBOG Fall Concert: Luna Li And Kuhlname
      SBOG Fall Concert: Luna Li And Kuhlname
  • Opinions
    • Wellesley is Worthy
      Wellesley is Worthy
    • Strength and Femininity: A Binary
      Strength and Femininity: A Binary
    • From ‘Love is Blind’ to ‘Notting Hill’:  How Media Shapes Our Understanding of Intimacy
      From ‘Love is Blind’ to ‘Notting Hill’: How Media Shapes Our Understanding of Intimacy
    • Editorials
    • Letters to Editors
  • Arts
    • A Review of CMAT’s new album, “Crazymad, For Me”
      A Review of CMAT’s new album, “Crazymad, For Me”
    • Is Mitski still an “Indie” Musician?
      Is Mitski still an “Indie” Musician?
    • Amazing representation packs a punch in Marvel’s Spider-Man 2
      Amazing representation packs a punch in Marvel’s Spider-Man 2
  • Sports
    • Student Athlete of the Month: Sara Maniscalco
      Student Athlete of the Month: Sara Maniscalco
    • Adrianne Haslet: Lessons from the Para-Athlete and Marathoner
      Adrianne Haslet: Lessons from the Para-Athlete and Marathoner
    • Wellesley Wins on Earn The W Day
      Wellesley Wins on Earn The W Day
  • Multimedia
    • Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
      Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
    • Photo of the Week
      Photo of the Week
    • “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
      “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
    • Podcasts
    • Photo Stories
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • Ellen Partners with Temu for her 12 Days of Giveaways, 2023!
      Ellen Partners with Temu for her 12 Days of Giveaways, 2023!
    • Winter is coming…
      Winter is coming…
    • Parsley’s Baby
      Parsley’s Baby
  • About
    • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
By Ariel Cohen Miscellanea, The Olive BranchNovember 10, 2015

The MSF Hospital Airstrike: Policy Versus People

Photo courtesy of Aljazeera

Earlier last month, nineteen people, including three children, were killed in an aerial attack by the U.S. forces that caused significant damage to a Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) trauma center in Afghanistan. Almost forty individuals were injured by the attack — a cause for a reflection of U.S. war policies and attitudes towards the Middle East.

According to U.S. law, the strike on the hospital was completely legal. The Law of War Manual published in June, notes that “all property located in enemy territory is regarded as enemy property regardless of its ownership.” While the Manual does include an amnesty clause aimed at protecting civilian hospitals, the definition of a civilian hospital is vague. Therefore, whether or not the MSF should have been provided protection remains unclear. Additionally, the policy specifically states that civilian hospitals should not be “close to military objectives” — an ambiguous requirement that allows the American government to sidestep legal accusations due to the hospital’s placement. The MSF hospital had previously provided its coordinates to the U.S. military to avoid harm, but there is no quantitative definition of “close.” The U.S. military has argued that the attack was “necessity of war,” perhaps because they were attempting to gather information on terrorists. However, because the hospital didn’t fall under military protection guidelines due to the hospital’s proximity to U.S. military targets, the destruction of lives was legally permissible according to the U.S. government.

Over the past several decades, war has become less clear than it once was. With the rise of terrorism and civilian participation in combat, the act of identifying who may pose a threat has become complicated. Troops may legally be ordered to endanger civilians or civilian property in order to identify terrorists and specific targets; as of January 2015, over 26,000 civilians died as a result of direct targeting techniques.  

Additionally, the American public has become accustomed to serial worldwide violence. Waging Nonviolence, a nonviolence-oriented news media outlet, holds that this American apathy is in part due to decline in the number of American deaths from overseas conflicts, while the death of civilians in American-involved conflicts continues to rise. Through their policies, Americans seem to value the lives of their citizens over innocent lives elsewhere.

The apathy of the American public has allowed for policies that permit attacks such as these. American’s physical and emotional removal from war results in the promotion of policies, as well as politicians that are unphased by civilian deaths. In the past, hollow excuses and justifications facilitated by governments solely for political gain, have been the only response to actions similar to this airstrike. Perhaps this time, the American people, if they are upset by this incidence, should exercise their rights as citizens of a democracy and  contact their representatives about their government’s policies. Additionally, lawmakers should carefully review international policies of war and consciously reflect upon the consequences of such policies.  The military should investigate how to best conduct policies with a little loss of life possible.   

One of the best cases in recent American history of civilian apathy and governmental malpractice is the case of Saddam Hussein. In the 1980s, in response to a developing Iranian revolution, the U.S. military provided Hussein with finances and weapons to bolster the Iraqi state. Hussein later used these same weapons to harm civilians in Iraq and Iran, and help fund terror attacks against the U.S.  Citizens should be aware of cases such as these to consider the potentially traumatic consequences of U.S. foreign policy.

Though the MSF strike was permissible by U.S. policy, it may have violated international humanitarian law. According the the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, everyone has the right to life and no state should seek the “destruction of any of the rights and freedoms” set forth by the Declaration. Under the incredibly vague International Bill of Human Rights, the U.S. government may be penalized for the event. Suffice to say that as Wellesley College students, we should seek education about issues such as these and ensure that we are not insensitive to the loss of innocent lives.  

<a href="https://thewellesleynews.com/byline/ariel-cohen/" rel="tag">Ariel Cohen</a>
<a href="https://thewellesleynews.com/byline/ariel-cohen/" rel="tag">Ariel Cohen</a>

Sabrina Leung ‘18 is the Digital Editor majoring in International Relations-Political Science with a minor in History. She is best reached at sleung@wellesley.edu or @sabrinatzleung on Twitter.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleResearch shows that BMI is an inaccurate measure of health
Next articleBathroom Hygiene Myths Debunked

You may also like

College Government President Tatiana Ivy Moise '21 speaks at commencement. She wears a mask and a graduation robe, and stands at a podium.

President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect

Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark

50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Wellesley News

    SECTIONS

  • News
  • Features
  • Opinions
  • Arts
  • Sports
  • Multimedia
  • Projects
  • About

    ABOUT

  • Contact
  • Join the News
  • Masthead
  • Editorial Board

    RESOURCES

  • Advertising
  • Submission
  • Subscribe

    CONTACT US

  • Contact
COPYRIGHT © 2023 THE WELLESLEY NEWS