• About
  • Editorial Board
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
The Wellesley News -
  • News and Features
    • Students With Medically Restricted Diets Struggle to Eat On Campus
      Students With Medically Restricted Diets Struggle to Eat On Campus
    • Students find new ways to celebrate Diwali
      Students find new ways to celebrate Diwali
    • Changing COVID-19 regulations impact students’ mental health
      Changing COVID-19 regulations impact students’ mental health
    • News
      • News in Brief
      • Nation & World
      • President’s Corner
      • Senate Report
    • Features
      • Alumnae Spotlight
      • Eye on Science
      • Faculty Focus
      • LGBTQIA+ Column
  • Opinions
    • Wellesley, why can’t you meet our dietary needs?
      Wellesley, why can’t you meet our dietary needs?
    • The block system is a joke
      The block system is a joke
    • Spineless nonpartisanship: how the Girl Scouts convinced me they no longer care about girls
      Spineless nonpartisanship: how the Girl Scouts convinced me they no longer care about girls
    • Staff Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
    • The Elephant in the Room
  • Arts
    • Music Performance Courses Adapt to an Altered Semester
      Music Performance Courses Adapt to an Altered Semester
    • Ben Wheatley’s adaptation of “Rebecca” fails to deliver compared to its classic counterpart
      Ben Wheatley’s adaptation of “Rebecca” fails to deliver compared to its classic counterpart
    • “Dash & Lily” Find Love, Stranded
      “Dash & Lily” Find Love, Stranded
    • Arts In The News
    • Reviews
    • Music Peek
  • Health and Wellness
    • No image
      Athletic impacts of Covid-19
    • No image
      A new kind of PE
    • No image
      Maintaining wellness as the cold sets in
    • Athlete of the Week
    • Boston Sports Update
    • The Vegan Digest
    • The SHE Corner
  • Miscellanea
    • No image
      Remote students experience existential crises; change class years in email signatures
    • President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
      President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
    • Your next on-campus romance isn’t going to work out
      Your next on-campus romance isn’t going to work out
    • The Artichoke
    • The Dose
    • The Olive Branch
    • Multimedia
      • Galleries
      • Infographics
      • Videos
By Amal Cheema OpinionsFebruary 10, 2016

Beyoncé is a Queen but she’s not India’s rani

Photo courtesy of Black Dog Films with River Studios.
 What does “Got me feeling drunk and high” have to do with Indian culture? Absolutely nothing. I’ll admit readily that this article is about cultural appropriation; however, it is also an exploration of who can be accused of that appropriation. Recently, Coldplay and Beyoncé who performed at the Super Bowl 50 and are acclaimed artists in their own right, released an enticing, reverberating single: “Hymn for the Weekend.” Though the song was originally intended to be a club hit, it unnecessarily uses Indian “exoticism” in its music video. Even the greatest skeptic can agree that the video is a series of fantasy shots: vibrant color clouds, saffron-robed men and dancing children. Consequently, “Hymn for the Weekend” has become the focus of cultural appropriation versus appreciation debate. Some argue that compared to Iggy Azalea’s “Bounce” or Major Lazer’s “Lean On,” the video does a better job of avoiding the brochure-worthy, whitewashed India. However, others question: with its religious iconography and token appearance of natives in the background, is it actually celebrating Indian culture? The answer is more complicated than a simple “yes” or “no.”

First, “Hymn for the Weekend” is about the intoxication of love, and with that tone, the video depicts an intoxicating India. South Asia has always been rendered and reduced to its “exotic nature.” The Western world has always fought to control and attain the spices from the land, and to, simply put, commercialize its equally “spicy” culture. On balance, many South Asians have worked with this commercialization and have tried to benefit as well, selling culture as a product. The Bollywood industry has glorified Westernism: the most eligible bachelor is American-educated, and Caucasians present at parties signify higher class status. Consequently, any association with the West validates social standing in the Bollywood plotlines. However, complicity in cultural appropriation doesn’t mean permission for exploitation. Rather, it doesn’t matter what your identity is. If you are using a culture and relegating it to the background to get more YouTube views or to make money for your own personal gain, it’s appropriation.

Second, neither Coldplay nor Beyoncé are immune to criticism. Chris Martin plays the casual observer role of Caucasian backpacker exploring an Indian village during what seems to be Holi; he notices the typical sensationalist, saffron-colored scenes and the religious iconography. While Coldplay are tourists in an Indian fantasy, Beyoncé’s imagery is a little harder to contextualize. Beyoncé, clad in Indian attire, stars as a Bollywood rani (“queen”). Throughout the video, she moves her hands in a mudra, which has deep religious significance in Bharatanatyam, a Indian classical dance.

In consideration, one can ask, “How can Beyoncé, a black woman, appropriate another culture?” Usually, the argument of cultural appropriation lies within power structures in play. Black Americans and African- Americans undoubtedly face oppression each day. South Asians also face discrimination and prejudice. And by no means will I compare those negative realities. In this case, I would like to offer the idea that Beyoncé is an American celebrity with a great deal of achieved power; and she rightfully owns it. So is Coldplay. However, South Asia is not America, and the queen, or the actress Beyoncé plays in the video, is not India’s rani. Likewise, India doesn’t exist solely for Coldplay to find spiritual awakening. Assuredly, people of all identities, including minorities, can appropriate.

Third, “Hymn for the Weekend” could have left room for self-representation. Some argue that seeing a dark- skinned woman as a Bollywood actress challenges the South Asian cultural obsession with whiteness. In the Indian subcontinent, the “fair” skin (i.e. whiteness) is often considered far more beautiful and valuable than darker skin. This idea is both ingrained and widespread in culture and popular media. Consequently, it can be empowering to see darker-skinned women celebrated in the Bollywood limelight, but Beyoncé is not Indian and does not, by default of being costumed as a Bollywood actress, serve as an empowering image. In the context of India, Beyoncé is an American powerhouse celebrity and arguably, an exception to the oppressive South Asian cultural norms. When we will see “dusky” South Asian actresses on the Bollywood screen, those norms will be challenged. Yet, in “Hymn for the Weekend,” the only time a Bollywood actress, Sonam Kapoor, appears in the video is for a ephemeral clip, in which she seems distant and elusive to the viewer. She is part of the background. Perhaps, Beyoncé didn’t need to costume herself into an Indian; rather, the part, if even necessary, could have been easily played an actual South Asian. Indeed, allowing for self-representation is more conducive to cultural appreciation.

And last, neither Coldplay and Beyoncé needed to use India as the backdrop. Though they both are extremely popular and beloved artists, more views don’t hurt. Given the social media focus on cultural appropriation, certainly the controversy around “Hymn for the Weekend” has helped increased viewership on YouTube to more than 35 million views. Sure, Coldplay and Beyoncé may admire India, but it’s hard to justify its use for commercial gain. And even if it celebrated India, it merely reaffirmed Western perspectives: vibrant powder smogs, poverty and dancing children. Neither Beyoncé nor Coldplay needed to follow the India-exhibition trend in pop culture and history. I respect and enjoy Beyoncé and Coldplay’s work, but it’s disappointing that they jumped on a bandwagon for this particular song.

So, what’s not cultural appropriation in the capitalist market? To some inconvenience, there is not a definitive answer. However, we can take Beyoncé’s anthem, “Formation,” as an exemplar because it demonstrates that minority culture can be appreciated and take power and agency in the media. “Formation” works for the reasons that it is true to Beyoncé’s own black experience and is self-representative. Whether “Hymn for the Weekend” was culturally appreciative or appropriative will always be fiercely debated. However, there are few, if any, exceptions as to who can appropriate another culture. Power structures are far more complicated than politically constructed race or gender. Popular media should not seek to represent admired cultures with outside perspectives but should instead allow for self-representation.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleBachelor Nation passively observes a damaging and sexist fantasy
Next articleHillary’s gender isn’t the crutch you think it is

You may also like

A piece of pizza missing topings.

Wellesley, why can’t you meet our dietary needs?

The block system is a joke

Spineless nonpartisanship: how the Girl Scouts convinced me they no longer care about girls

1 Comment

  • Nick says:
    February 12, 2016 at 3:50 PM

    Cultural appropriation is an asinine concept, human beings cultural and technical achievements belong to one another, not to whichever ethnicity originated them. Is it cultural appropriation for an Indian, a black person, or anyone not white to play guitar, piano, or a violin because white people invented those instruments? Is it cultural appropriation for them to own light bulbs when it was white people who invented them and brought them to market? We could go down this rabbit hole forever, human achievements belong to human beings, all of them, quit throwing up artificial and utterly unnecessary barriers that do nothing but divide us.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

Top Articles

Sorry. No data so far.

Recent Tweets

Tweets by @Wellesley_News

The independent student newspaper of Wellesley College since 1901.

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

  • About
  • Editorial Board
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
COPYRIGHT © 2021 THE WELLESLEY NEWS
Back to top