• About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
The Wellesley News -
  • News and Features
    • The Wellesley (COVID) 100
      The Wellesley (COVID) 100
    • In memory of Professor Rebecca Summerhays
      In memory of Professor Rebecca Summerhays
    • Trans flag controversy: College power washes staircase after trans flag is painted over Harry Potter spray paint
      Trans flag controversy: College power washes staircase after trans flag is painted over Harry Potter spray paint
    • News
      • News in Brief
      • Nation & World
      • President’s Corner
      • Senate Report
    • Features
      • Alumnae Spotlight
      • Eye on Science
      • Faculty Focus
      • LGBTQIA+ Column
  • Opinions
    • The News in Conversation: Wellesley Against Mass Incarceration
      The News in Conversation: Wellesley Against Mass Incarceration
    • Editorial Board calls for keeping up trans flag murals
      Editorial Board calls for keeping up trans flag murals
    • No, Elon Musk’s Twitter will not restore free speech
      No, Elon Musk’s Twitter will not restore free speech
    • Staff Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
    • The Elephant in the Room
  • Arts
    • Chloe Gong could publish her grocery list and I’d pay $20 for it (Books Before Boys review)
      Chloe Gong could publish her grocery list and I’d pay $20 for it (Books Before Boys review)
    • RIP to Wanda, the male betta fish (Books Before Boys review)
      RIP to Wanda, the male betta fish (Books Before Boys review)
    • When talking to ghosts only worsens your existential dread (Books Before Boys review)
      When talking to ghosts only worsens your existential dread (Books Before Boys review)
    • Arts In The News
    • Reviews
    • Music Peek
    • Books Before Boys
  • Health and Wellness
    • February Student Athlete of the Month
      February Student Athlete of the Month
    • Athletics Update
      Athletics Update
    • Victoria Garrick Speaks on Mental Health
      Victoria Garrick Speaks on Mental Health
    • Athlete of the Week
    • Boston Sports Update
    • The Vegan Digest
    • The SHE Corner
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • Wellesley News Leadership Changes Completely Peacefully Without Any Suspicious Disappearances At All
      Wellesley News Leadership Changes Completely Peacefully Without Any Suspicious Disappearances At All
    • Solve Your Connection Problems With Wellesley Insecure
      Solve Your Connection Problems With Wellesley Insecure
    • Mayhem strikes Wellesley as paper towels removed from campus
      Mayhem strikes Wellesley as paper towels removed from campus
  • Miscellanea
    • President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
      President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
    • Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
      Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
    • 50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
      50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
    • The Dose
    • The Olive Branch
    • Multimedia
      • Galleries
      • Infographics
      • Videos
By Elinor Higgins Eye on Science, Features, News and FeaturesFebruary 10, 2016

Scientists construct an embryo derived from three parents

Image courtesy of NPR.

Scientists in Britain are waiting for consent from government officials to carry out a procedure that will allow a baby to be born with genetic material from three people. Though this genetic manipulation is intended to cure hereditary mitochondrial defects, many are expressing ethical concerns about this experimental procedure.

A fear of eugenics has existed ever since the discovery of gene manipulation. Eugenics is the science of improving the human population by controlling for desirable hereditary characteristics. Controversy lies in what constitutes a desirable characteristic and who gets to decide this.

Despite these dilemmas, there are those who see genetic manipulation as an instrument of good. These people include a team of scientists working in Britain at Newcastle University. This team, lead by Dr. Doug Turnbull, is focusing on finding a way to combat the devastating effects of defective mitochondrial DNA. The organelle mitochondrion is a crucial part of all human cells. These organelles are the sites of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) production. ATP provides “energy” for the cell and is essential for many molecular processes.

Interestingly, mitochondria have their own DNA. It is widely accepted that this is because mitochondria were once independent organisms, slowly developing from symbiont to a true, inheritable part of the cell. Because humans inherit their mitochondria, the mitochondrial DNA is derived from their mothers. In most cases, this fact simply provides an interesting connection to a person’s maternal history, should they want to explore it. For some potential mothers, however, there is a fear of passing on defective mitochondrial DNA to their children.

Though the severity of these problems can vary, babies who inherit mitochondrial defects often die just weeks or months after being born. Their cells cannot harness usable energy and therefore waste away. In order to prevent these tragedies, Dr. Turnbull and his team have come up with what they see as a potential solution for the problem.

It is possible to collect healthy eggs from a woman with working mitochondrial DNA, fertilize it in vitro and then remove all of the DNA from the nucleus while leaving the healthy mitochondria behind. This nuclear DNA is the genetic material most people are familiar with. It determines hair and eye color, height and other characteristics. Once this nuclear DNA is removed, it can be replaced with the nuclear DNA from an embryo created by the would-be parents. This combination results in an embryo with both healthy nuclear and mitochondrial DNA.

There is, of course, a return to the question of ethics. The embryo contains the genes of three people, though in varying amounts. Additionally, the procedure is intended to improve a potential human being. Though it may not seem like a bad thing to prevent the premature death of a child, some worry this would set a dangerous precedent for the creation of so-called “designer babies.”

One such critic is David King, a molecular biologist who runs a watchdog group called Human Genetics Alert.

“You’re making changes which we may not know the actual consequences until that person is born, which could include damaging effects on that person’s health,” King said in an interview with NPR. “Those problems would be passed down the generations to that person’s descendants. And obviously that’s something that you don’t want to do.”

Due to these concerns, this procedure is being reviewed by British government officials, and their decision will determine whether the experiment is allowed to continue.

There is a strong and often valid fear of carrying out such experimental procedures on humans when the long-term effects are virtually unknown. Despite concerns, a new age of human reproduction is beginning, and this will not be the last case where ethics must be weighed against scientific capabilities.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleMulticultural Column: 2/10
Next articleIdeafest’s new initiatives undergo first stage of implementation

You may also like

The Wellesley (COVID) 100

In memory of Professor Rebecca Summerhays

Trans flag controversy: College power washes staircase after trans flag is painted over Harry Potter spray paint

1 Comment

  • Pingback: CIENTÍFICOS INGLESES PUEDEN CREAR EMBRIONES DERIVADOS DE TRES PADRES | Manipulación genética

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

Top Articles

Sorry. No data so far.

Recent Tweets

Tweets by @Wellesley_News

The independent student newspaper of Wellesley College since 1901.

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

  • About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
COPYRIGHT © 2022 THE WELLESLEY NEWS
Back to top