facebook icon facebook icon facebook icon
  • About
  • ADS
  • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
  • Subscribe
The Wellesley News -
  • News
    • Wellesley students join thousands marching for Palestine in Boston
      Wellesley students join thousands marching for Palestine in Boston
    • Wellesley students react to recent events in Israel & Palestine
      Wellesley students react to recent events in Israel & Palestine
    • No image
      Cabinet Column 10/25/23
    • Senate Report
    • News in Brief
  • Features
    • Slater International Center Features Culture Show
      Slater International Center Features Culture Show
    • Trans Author Aiden Thomas Visits Wellesley
      Trans Author Aiden Thomas Visits Wellesley
    • The Beauty of the Bamiyan: Former Wellesley Professor Deborah Klimburg-Salter’s Lecture on Historic Valley in Afghanistan
      The Beauty of the Bamiyan: Former Wellesley Professor Deborah Klimburg-Salter’s Lecture on Historic Valley in Afghanistan
  • Opinions
    • Wellesley is Worthy
      Wellesley is Worthy
    • Strength and Femininity: A Binary
      Strength and Femininity: A Binary
    • From ‘Love is Blind’ to ‘Notting Hill’:  How Media Shapes Our Understanding of Intimacy
      From ‘Love is Blind’ to ‘Notting Hill’: How Media Shapes Our Understanding of Intimacy
    • Editorials
    • Letters to Editors
  • Arts
    • An Indigenous perspective on “Killers of the Flower Moon”
      An Indigenous perspective on “Killers of the Flower Moon”
    • Now and Then: The Newest Beatles Song
      Now and Then: The Newest Beatles Song
    • The behind-the-scenes battles that dimmed “Mona Lisa Smile”
      The behind-the-scenes battles that dimmed “Mona Lisa Smile”
  • Sports
    • Student Athlete of the Month: Sara Maniscalco
      Student Athlete of the Month: Sara Maniscalco
    • Adrianne Haslet: Lessons from the Para-Athlete and Marathoner
      Adrianne Haslet: Lessons from the Para-Athlete and Marathoner
    • Wellesley Wins on Earn The W Day
      Wellesley Wins on Earn The W Day
  • Multimedia
    • Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
      Wellesley Celebrates Flower Sunday 2023
    • Photo of the Week
      Photo of the Week
    • “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
      “Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton
    • Podcasts
    • Photo Stories
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • Ellen Partners with Temu for her 12 Days of Giveaways, 2023!
      Ellen Partners with Temu for her 12 Days of Giveaways, 2023!
    • Winter is coming…
      Winter is coming…
    • Parsley’s Baby
      Parsley’s Baby
  • About
    • Masthead
    • Editorial Board
By Tanvee Varma Miscellanea, The DoseOctober 18, 2016

Clinton vs. Trump on Healthcare

Photo courtesy of CNN

The first and second presidential debates on September 26th and October 9th, respectively, created quite a stir. In the first presidential debate, issues such as immigration, income inequality, and mass incarceration were debated. However, amid the critical national issues discussed, a very important topic was left out: health care. According to CBS News/New York Times poll, health care is considered the most important issue of this election for approximately 16 percent of Americans. Healthcare trails just behind the economy & jobs and national security & immigration. In the second presidential debate, health policy was discussed only briefly. Clinton argued that she would “fix” Obamacare whereas Trump said that he would repeal it and replace it “with something absolutely much less expensive and something that works.” While it is likely, if not almost guaranteed, that health policy will be discussed in more detail in the last presidential debate, it’s critical to ask, how do Clinton and Trump actually plan on lowering costs and improving healthcare for all Americans?

Hillary Clinton, the Democratic presidential nominee, plans on actively defending Affordable Care Act, which currently protects more than 20 million people throughout the United States. In addition, she plans on expanding coverage by making “public option” possible, a government-run health insurance agency that would compete with other private insurance companies. Public option would, according to Clinton, expand consumer choice and lower costs by introducing competition into the health insurance marketplace. She also plans on providing tax credit to those whose premiums and out-of-pocket health insurance costs exceed five percent of their income. Her health policy plan would allow Americans access to health insurance, regardless of immigration status.

On the other hand, the Republican presidential nominee, Donald Trump, has promised to repeal the Affordable Care Act on the first day of his administration. Instead of requiring all Americans to buy insurance, he plans on allowing individuals who buy private insurance to deduct premiums from their taxes. However, Trump’s tax credits would benefit higher-income Americans more than lower-income Americans. Overall, Trump believes in the power of free market principles and giving power back to the states to increase access to affordable, quality, health care. This belief manifests in policy proposals that include modifying the law that prohibits the sale of health insurance across state lines and on giving states a fixed amount to pay for Medicaid, rather than the federal government paying for a fixed share of each enrollee’s costs.

How do Clinton’s and Trump’s policies play out in improving health coverage and decreasing the federal deficit?


 

A report from the Rand Corp. found that the number of uninsured Americans would soar by 20.3 million under Trump’s plan. This would largely be the result of Trump’s repeal of the Affordable Care Act. However, Clinton’s plan would lower the number of uninsured by 9.1 million due to her plan to offer tax credit to aid individuals with lower or moderate-incomes to pay for premiums and out-of-pocket costs.

While Clinton’s proposed plan would significantly increase health coverage, her plan will be quite costly for the national deficit. Under Clinton’s plan, the deficit would soar by $88.5 billion, due to the plan to provide tax credit to those whose individual premium and out-of-pocket costs exceed five percent of their income. On the other hand, Trump’s plan would increase the federal deficit only by $5.8 billion due to tax deduction and allowing sale of health insurance across state lines. Trump’s plan to change the Medicaid policy by providing fixed grants to states would also save the government $33 billion.

In an election in which policy discussions have become muddled by controversy and ugly rhetoric, it is becoming increasingly important to evaluate the implications of each nominee’s policy from an objective standpoint. While Trump’s healthcare policy plan adds to the federal deficit far less than Clinton’s, his plan would also terminate health care coverage for many Americans and reverse the progress made by Obamacare.

<a href="https://thewellesleynews.com/byline/tanvee-varma/" rel="tag">Tanvee Varma</a>
<a href="https://thewellesleynews.com/byline/tanvee-varma/" rel="tag">Tanvee Varma</a>

Sabrina Leung ‘18 is the Digital Editor majoring in International Relations-Political Science with a minor in History. She is best reached at sleung@wellesley.edu or @sabrinatzleung on Twitter.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleThe Alchemist’s Open Letter to Wellesley
Next article“Stronger Together” Rally with Chelsea Clinton

You may also like

College Government President Tatiana Ivy Moise '21 speaks at commencement. She wears a mask and a graduation robe, and stands at a podium.

President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect

Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark

50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Wellesley News

    SECTIONS

  • News
  • Features
  • Opinions
  • Arts
  • Sports
  • Multimedia
  • Projects
  • About

    ABOUT

  • Contact
  • Join the News
  • Masthead
  • Editorial Board

    RESOURCES

  • Advertising
  • Submission
  • Subscribe

    CONTACT US

  • Contact
COPYRIGHT © 2023 THE WELLESLEY NEWS