• About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
The Wellesley News -
  • News and Features
    • Professor Phillip Levine Discusses “A Problem of Fit”
      Professor Phillip Levine Discusses “A Problem of Fit”
    • CS Department shifts CS 111 course structure
      CS Department shifts CS 111 course structure
    • WAMI and WRJ host discussion on criminalization of abortion
      WAMI and WRJ host discussion on criminalization of abortion
    • News
      • News in Brief
      • Nation & World
      • President’s Corner
      • Senate Report
    • Features
      • Alumnae Spotlight
      • Eye on Science
      • Faculty Focus
      • LGBTQIA+ Column
  • Opinions
    • Andrew tate: ending the cycle of toxic masculinity
      Andrew tate: ending the cycle of toxic masculinity
    • Turn it off: healing from news fatigue in the digital age
      Turn it off: healing from news fatigue in the digital age
    • Let them eat bread: the unequal effects of food price inflation
      Let them eat bread: the unequal effects of food price inflation
    • Staff Editorial
    • Letters to the Editor
    • The Elephant in the Room
  • Arts
    • The 95th Academy Awards Nominations: The Cool and The Controversial
      The 95th Academy Awards Nominations: The Cool and The Controversial
    • Lucy Dacus Brings a Minimal Yet Powerful Performance to Northeastern University
      Lucy Dacus Brings a Minimal Yet Powerful Performance to Northeastern University
    • “Glass Onion” Takes Shots at Easy Targets
      “Glass Onion” Takes Shots at Easy Targets
    • Arts In The News
    • Reviews
    • Music Peek
    • Books Before Boys
  • Sports and Wellness
    • Student-Athlete of October
      Student-Athlete of October
    • Athletics Update Oct. 19, 2022
      Athletics Update Oct. 19, 2022
    • The Case for Body Neutrality
      The Case for Body Neutrality
    • Athlete of the Week
    • Boston Sports Update
    • The Vegan Digest
    • The SHE Corner
  • The Wellesley Snooze
    • Rejected Snooze Articles for the Week
      Rejected Snooze Articles for the Week
    • Happy Valentine’s Day from Spog
      Happy Valentine’s Day from Spog
    • The Four Best Places to Loudly FaceTime Someone on Campus
      The Four Best Places to Loudly FaceTime Someone on Campus
  • Miscellanea
    • President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
      President’s Column: The Butterfly Effect
    • Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
      Administrators shocked to learn that students dislike being left in dark
    • 50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
      50 Lies You Tell Yourself in Order to Survive Until Graduation
    • The Dose
    • The Olive Branch
    • Multimedia
      • Galleries
      • Infographics
      • Videos
By Jane Vaughan OpinionsApril 21, 2017

Victims of violence should not have their pasts scrutinized by media

Photo courtesy of United Airlines

Whenever instances of abuse or violence occur and are widely spread over social media, a lot of information will often appear about the backgrounds of victims and perpetrators. Some believe that a person’s history may have something to do with what happened, as if this history excuses or explains it in some way. However, I disagree with this approach. I believe that a victim’s history is irrelevant when discussing their abuse and that incidents should be considered solely in the context in which they occurred.

A United Airlines flight on Sunday, April 9, scheduled to fly from Chicago to Louisville, was overbooked. The airline asked four passengers to give up their seats for crew members who were needed in Louisville the next day. United claims that it chose the passengers that were to debark based on criteria that included frequent-flier status, check-in time and fare type, among others. For their cooperation, the airlines offered monetary compensation. Three of the chosen passengers left quietly. The fourth, Dr. David Dao, 69, refused to leave. He is a physician who needed to see patients the next day in Louisville. He was then forcibly wrestled from his seat by Chicago aviation authorities and dragged by his arms down the aisle of the plane. Multiple videos surfaced online of Dao being pulled down the aisle, face bloodied. His lawyer later explained that Dao suffered a broken nose, a concussion and two knocked-out teeth.

Since then, United Airlines has faced enormous backlash about their violent and inappropriate tactics. Many have seen it as an example of airline greed, showcasing how far these companies will go to sell their seats. United CEO Oscar Munoz at first blamed Dao for what happened, claiming that the passenger had been belligerent and uncooperative. He has since apologized and says that United is working on addressing the incident.

Dao received an outpouring of support from people who had seen the video. In recent days, however, more information has surfaced about him. Specifically, there are accusations circulating that he has a criminal record. He was apparently convicted in 2005 on six counts of obtaining drugs by fraud and deceit and was also convicted for writing prescriptions for a male patient in exchange for sexual favors. The Kentucky state medical licensing board issued a suspension that was lifted in 2015, and Dao is currently under severe restrictions while he practices internal medicine.

Learning about Dao’s background introduces the question of whether or not a victim’s past should come into play when assessing the situation. But a victim’s personality should be separated from their victimization.

I believe that it is important to separate a victim’s past from their abuse. Whatever their history may be, no person should be violently dragged from an airplane for refusing to give up their seat, and especially should not suffer a concussion and other injuries along the way. Past wrongdoings do not excuse immediate abuse.

This discussion is similar to one that emerged after Trayvon Martin was fatally shot by George Zimmerman in February 2012. When he was killed, Martin was walking home from the drugstore and was carrying Skittles and Arizona Watermelon Fruit Juice Cocktail, which, when combined with dextromethorphan (DXM) cough syrup, create ‘lean,’ a substance that can cause psychosis and aggression.

Some saw Martin’s purchases as an excuse for his murder, especially when his autopsy revealed that his liver showed damage consistent with DXM abuse. Some said he deserved it, emphasizing that he had been suspended from school three times in the month before he was killed. Others shrugged it off as just something unfortunate that happened. For them, Martin’s alleged drug use excused, or at least explained, his murder.

Trayvon Martin’s drug use was not a reason or an excuse for his murder. He was just a 17-year-old kid walking home. A similar situation arises with Dao. While his criminal past is unsettling, it does not justify or explain what happened on the United flight.

It may be true that Dao was belligerent on the flight. Another passenger reports that when Dao was first asked to leave, he shouted at the flight attendants that he was being singled out because he was Chinese. However, his aggression does not warrant a broken nose and other injuries. Any person in that situation may have done the same thing. Voicing your rights does not merit physical abuse.

A victim’s history is especially irrelevant because the perpetrators did not know about their history at the time of the abuse. The Chicago aviation authorities had no way of knowing about Dao’s criminal record; they simply acted violently towards an innocent passenger. Since his background was not known at the time, it was irrelevant at that point and is thus irrelevant now.

When discussing these incidents, or those that are similar, it is crucial to keep them solely in the context of the abuse that occurred. What matters is that a 69-year-old man was violently dragged from a United Airlines flight and sustained multiple injuries, not that he had a criminal past. If we continue to expand upon these events so that they include years of backstory, the abuse itself is overshadowed and taken out of context. Keeping the circumstances of these events in mind allows us to address the abuse or injustices that occurred without excusing unwarranted violence.

Share on

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Google +
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Previous articleTrump’s presidency must remain topical in journalism
Next articleCampus discourse is integral for intellectual growth

You may also like

Logos of social media apps such as Twitter, Tiktok, Netflix, Spotify, and Discord.

Andrew tate: ending the cycle of toxic masculinity

Abstract painting of various boxes meant to imply computer and phone screens

Turn it off: healing from news fatigue in the digital age

A collection of a wide variety of foods in the colors of the rainbow

Let them eat bread: the unequal effects of food price inflation

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

Top Articles

  • Logos of social media apps such as Twitter, Tiktok, Netflix, Spotify, and Discord. Andrew tate: ending the cycle of toxic masculinity
  • Stone-Davis dining staff report mistreatment
  • The 95th Academy Awards Nominations: The Cool and The Contro...
  • A collection of a wide variety of foods in the colors of the rainbow Let them eat bread: the unequal effects of food price inflat...
  • Red envelope that contains money to celebrate the Lunar New Year. America’s cultural appropriation is a modern form of i...

Recent Tweets

Tweets by @Wellesley_News

The independent student newspaper of Wellesley College since 1901.

Sign up to receive our weekly digest in your inbox

* indicates required

  • About
  • Editorial Board
    • Staff Writers
  • Advertise
  • Join Us
  • Archives
COPYRIGHT © 2023 THE WELLESLEY NEWS
Back to top